***URGENT*** Skeptic Exchange will close down very soon unless you visit Area 51 and vote for it!
0

What is a Ad hominem Logical Fallacy? And what are the classic examples?

flag

3 Answers

2

Here's an example:

"Rush Limbaugh says that drug dealers should get long prison sentences? He was addicted to pain killers, what a hypocrite. Nothing he says is credible."

What makes it an ad hominem fallacy is that the rebuttal discredits the person making the claim, without addressing the facts of the actual claim itself. You can't really discredit a hypothesis simply by discrediting one person making that claim.

link|flag
Much like Creationists trying to link Darwin and Hitler. – rjstelling Nov 5 at 13:32
That's Godwin's law: "As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches one." And it isn't just creationists. =) – johnfx Nov 8 at 20:02
1

Ad hominem (or 'to the man') is when in a debate, someone attacks their opponent rather than the arguments (s)he is putting forward.

Classic examples may be...

"You're wrong; you're a Socialist."

"I happen to know for a fact that you've had several extra-marital affairs. Why should we listen to anything you have to say on morality?"

"He used to work for Big pharma so everything he says is really just propoganda for the big corporations."

link|flag
0

Without wishing to split hairs the above is not strictly true:

Another version of this fallacy is seen a lot in work or politics and is as follows:

Statement "This project was a complete failure and achieved none of its objectives."

Answer "I worked really hard on this project."

The answer does not attack the first person rather it promotes the respondant, however the effect is the same - the argument is not answered.

link|flag
Even barristers can fall into this fallacy, but usually the judge stops them befor a jury is swayed by it. – Travelling Show and Tell Man Jan 26 at 14:12

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.